Thomas Cothren of New York notes that the New York Giants, one of the most storied franchises in the National Football League (NFL), have had a fascinating history of quarterbacks. From legendary figures who led the team to Super Bowl triumphs to those promising talents steering the team today, each quarterback has left an indelible mark on the franchise as a whole. In this article, Thomas Cothren of New York will rank these quarterbacks, considering their impact, achievements, and contributions to the Giants.

1. Eli Manning

Eli Manning stands at the pinnacle of Giants quarterbacks. A two-time Super Bowl MVP, Manning’s heroics in Super Bowls XLII and XLVI are the stuff of legend. His career with the Giants spanned 16 seasons, during which he amassed 57,023 passing yards and 366 touchdowns. His ironman streak of 210 consecutive starts is a testament to his durability and commitment.

2. Phil Simms

Phil Simms, best known for his spectacular performance in Super Bowl XXI, is another Giants great. Thomas Cothren explains that Simms spent his entire 14-year career with the Giants, leading them to their first Super Bowl victory in 1986. With a career completion rate of 55.4% and 199 touchdowns, his precision and consistency were his hallmarks.

3. Charlie Conerly

Charlie Conerly, the quarterback from the 1950s, guided the Giants to three NFL Championship games, winning one in 1956. His career stats include 19,488 passing yards and 173 touchdowns. Conerly was known for his leadership and gritty play, making him a beloved figure of Giants history.

4. Y.A. Tittle

Y.A. Tittle, even having only spent four seasons with the Giants, left an indelible impact. Thomas Cothren of New York remarks how Tittle led the Giants to three straight NFL Eastern Conference titles and was named the NFL MVP in 1963. His tenure with the Giants was marked by impressive stats, including 96 touchdowns and over 10,000 passing yards.

5. Kerry Collins

Kerry Collins, who led the Giants to Super Bowl XXXV, was a key figure in the early 2000s. His strong arm and resilience helped the Giants stay competitive. Collins threw for 16,875 yards and 81 touchdowns during his five seasons with the team.

6. Fran Tarkenton

Fran Tarkenton, better known for his time with the Minnesota Vikings, also had a significant stint with the Giants. He played for the Giants from 1967 to 1971, throwing for over 13,000 yards and 103 touchdowns. His mobility and playmaking ability were certainly ahead of his time.

7. Jeff Hostetler

Jeff Hostetler, though often a backup, played a crucial role in the Giants’ Super Bowl XXV victory. Taking over late in the 1990 season, Hostetler’s efficient play and composure under pressure were vital for the Giants’ championship run.

8. Daniel Jones

Daniel Jones, the current quarterback, shows promise with his dual-threat capability. Although his career with the Giants is still unfolding, his athleticism and arm strength mark him as a quarterback to keep an eye on. Thomas Cothren of New York is hopeful he can bounce back in 2024.

9. Dave Brown

Dave Brown, who played for the Giants in the mid-90s, had moments of brilliance, but struggled with consistency. He amassed 10,248 passing yards and 44 touchdowns during his tenure with the Giants.

10. Scott Brunner

Scott Brunner, playing in the early 80s, is often remembered for leading the Giants to a playoff berth in 1981. His time as a starter was short, but he showed potential during his stint, according to Thomas Cothren of New York.

The New York Giants have a rich and fascinating quarterback history, marked by a long line of talented and accomplished quarterbacks who have each left their own unique mark on the franchise. Eli Manning, for instance, is widely regarded as one of the greatest quarterbacks in Giants history, having led the team to two unforgettable Super Bowl victories, including one over the undefeated New England Patriots. His clutch performances in these games will forever be remembered by Giants fans everywhere.

Other quarterbacks who have played a significant role in shaping the Giants’ legacy include Phil Simms, who led the team to their first Super Bowl win in 1987, and Y.A. Tittle, who helped the team reach three straight NFL Championship games in the early 1960s. These quarterbacks, among others, have helped establish the Giants as one of the most storied franchises in NFL history.

Looking to the future, the Giants have high hopes for Daniel Jones, their young and promising quarterback who was drafted in 2019. Jones has already shown flashes of brilliance in his rookie year, and many fans and analysts believe in his potential to become one of the league’s top quarterbacks in the years to come.

As the Giants continue to evolve and build for the future, one thing is clear according to Thomas Cothren of New York: the quarterback position will always be a critical factor in their success. Whether it’s Manning, Simms, Tittle, Jones, or someone else, the Giants’ quarterback will always be a source of excitement, hope, and pride for fans everywhere.