For most of their history, the Steelers have stuck to a tried-and-true formula: physicality, a punishing ground game, and a defense that leaves opponents gasping for air. It’s a formula that’s brought them plenty of unforgettable moments and a handful of Super Bowl trophies. But as the NFL evolves, a big question looms: can Pittsburgh hold onto this identity and still hang with the league’s elite?

The NFL has changed. Rules now favor offenses more than ever, putting defenses in a tough spot. Not too long ago, the Steelers’ defense struck fear into opponents. Offenses lined up against guys like James Harrison and Ryan Clark, knowing a big hit was just a play away. That kind of fear doesn’t exist anymore—not because the Steelers’ players lack toughness, but because the league has made it clear that dangerous hits aren’t welcome in today’s game.

Defenses can’t rely on intimidation or brute force like they used to. Now, it’s all about strategy and schemes, which puts offenses—and especially quarterbacks and receivers—a step ahead. Wide receivers no longer hesitate to run across the middle, an area that used to be a no-go zone for anyone worried about getting their bell rung. The days of hearing, “He’s afraid to go across the middle,” are long gone.

What’s the result? Offenses are faster, flashier, and tougher to stop. So far this season, the Steelers offense is averaging 23.5 points per game, which ranks 12th in the league. Meanwhile, the top five teams are all putting up over 28 points per game. On the other hand, Pittsburgh’s defense is holding its own, allowing just 19.9 points per game—sixth-best in the league. But against high-powered offenses, cracks are showing. In their last three games—two against Super Bowl contenders—they’ve given up 25 points per game.

Here’s the hard truth: the Steelers’ run-first, grind-it-out style leaves them with no margin for error. To beat the league’s best, they have to play nearly perfect football—limit turnovers, force takeaways, and make every opportunity count. But recent losses to the Eagles and Ravens have shown how tough that is. Costly mistakes and missed chances have been the difference.

If the Steelers want to truly compete with today’s top teams, they need an offense that can create chunk plays and put up points when things don’t go according to plan. That doesn’t mean abandoning the run—it just means finding a better balance.

Take Najee Harris, for example. He’s been rock-solid, racking up over 3,200 rushing yards in his first three seasons—more than 1,000 yards a year. That’s a first for any Steeler. But his 3.9 yards-per-carry average shows he’s grinding out tough yards, relying on a heavy workload. Meanwhile, Jaylen Warren is averaging 4.8 yards per carry, almost a full yard more. Granted, Warren’s seen fewer carries, but his efficiency stands out. It’s worth noting that Warren often runs against lighter defensive fronts in passing situations. While both backs have their role, imagine what this running attack would look like if offenses had to respect the pass no matter the situation or which back was in the game.

Over the past few years, we weren’t in position to have an efficient passing attack. This season feels different because the Steelers finally have a quarterback in Russell Wilson who can get it done through the air. His career touchdown-to-interception ratio of 3-to-1 shows he’s a guy you can trust to take care of the ball and make plays when needed.

Running the ball should stay part of the Steelers’ DNA, but shifting to a pass-first mindset could unlock the full potential of this offense. The temporary loss of star receiver George Pickens has been a setback, but Calvin Austin III has stepped up in a big way. He’s proving he can be a legitimate weapon, even when Pickens returns. Pair them with tight end Pat Freiermuth, and you’ve got a trio that can cause headaches for any defense.

Arthur Smith, the offensive coordinator, needs to make one thing clear: the Steelers’ playmakers should drive this offense, something he was criticized for in Atlanta also. Role players can have their moments but they should be few and far between. There shouldn’t be games where players such as Freiermuth has only three targets. If there is one receiver on the field, it shouldn’t be Scotty Miller. Pickens, Freiermuth, Austin, Warren and Harris need to be the focus. As a fan, I’d rather live or die by the hands of our best players than play it safe.

If the Steelers can build a dynamic and efficient passing attack, defenses will have no choice but to respect it. That opens up more running lanes for Harris and Warren, creating the kind of balanced attack that’s tough to stop. With all do respect, defenses have no fear of players like Ben Skowronek and Scotty Miller. They have produced for us, and we all should be grateful for their contributions, but we need our best players on the field as much as possible.

Pittsburgh doesn’t need to ditch its identity as a tough, physical team. They just need to evolve. The NFL is now a league where chunk  plays and quick strikes rule the day. By embracing that reality, the Steelers can stay true to their roots while building a team capable of competing for championships.

So, is it time for the Steelers to change their philosophy? It might just be the key to their future success.

Continue to check out the Steel Curtain Network for Steelers news and updates.

Stay Blessed and Stay Positive… “Here We Go”